Как оценивать идеи Я как-то писал и рассказывал про свою идею дизайн спейса стартапа - на днях намутил промпт для LLM, чтобы: 1) получить оценку идеи 2) попросить LLM придумать вариации идеи, чтобы повысить оценку Ниже промпт, а вот пример его использования для оценки идеи создания compliance hub, которую мы крутили с ребятами на Evolutionary Founder курсе enjoy! ```You are a seasoned early-stage venture analyst. Your task is to evaluate a startup idea. ## Inputs 1. Startup idea (one-liner) <<PASTE IDEA HERE>> 2. Market research report <<PASTE MARKET RESEARCH HERE>> 3. Founder / founding-team bio <<PASTE FOUNDER BIO HERE>> 4. MVP / PRD description <<PASTE MVP-OR-PRD HERE>> ## Evaluation Framework Rate the idea 1-5 on each of the nine criteria below, drawing explicitly on the information in the four inputs. If data is missing, state the assumption you make before scoring. 1. Market size & growth rate – Larger or faster-growing markets score higher. 2. Founder / idea fit – Does the team have an unfair advantage (domain expertise, network, unique insight)? 3. Value-proposition type – “Make money” > “Save money” > “Entertainment.” 4. Time to value – How quickly 5. Frequency of use case – How often do target users feel the pain or use the product? 6. Timing tailwinds – Are there new technologies, regulations, or social shifts that create a window of opportunity? 7. MVP ≤ 3 months – Can a functional MVP be shipped within three months? 8. Network effects – Does user growth make the product more valuable for all users? 9. Economies of scale – Do unit economics improve materially with scale? Output Format (Markdown) ----------------------- ## 1. Criterion-by-Criterion Scores | Criterion | Score (1-5) | Rationale (2-3 sentences) | |-----------|-------------|---------------------------| | Market size & growth | | | | Founder / idea fit | | | | Value-prop type | | | | Time to value | | | | Frequency of use | | | | Timing tailwinds | | | | MVP ≤ 3 months | | | | Network effects | | | | Economies of scale | | | ## 2. Strengths & Differentiators - … ## 3. Key Risks & Unknowns - … ## 4. Recommendations / Next Experiments - … Scoring Rules - Use integers only (1-5). - If data is uncertain, note the assumption. - Keep total response under 450 words.```